• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

SLA Media

SLAMedia is a publication of the news for the Science Leadership Academy community. Writers come from the student body in 10th, 11th, and 12th grades. We work in unison to create a functioning paper with biweekly postings on a variety of events.

  • News
  • Features
  • Sports
  • A&E
  • Op/Ed
  • Multimedia
  • About

Editorial: Solving the School District

February 26, 2013 by lpahomov Leave a Comment

Last year, the School district of Philadelphia decided to close several schools due to “poor performance”. Displaced students were forced to attend their nearest elementary or high school which, in most cases, meant another underperforming public school. The application deadline for magnet schools like SLA and Masterman had long since passed, but this didn’t really matter since most students would not have had much of a chance anyway.

The gap in quality between comprehensive high schools and magnet schools was not always this wide. In fact, many American communities pride themselves on their local schools, and do not feel the need to create an alternative high school for the “smart” kids. As the schools around us close one by one, SLA and other Philadelphia magnet schools may have to face an uncomfortable question:

Are we the problem?

Like other magnet schools, SLA is a safe place where mentally gifted and accelerated students can thrive without being dragged down by their less-motivated peers. We pull together the most advanced students from all over the city to create a culturally diverse, academically rigorous environment that pushes its students to work hard and fulfill their potential. This makes for a rich high school experience that often leads to admission to college, a wonderful prospect if you’re lucky enough to be accepted.

Students attending magnet schools account for only a fraction of Philadelphia’s high-schoolers. The vast majority of this year’s eighth graders will attend a comprehensive public high school, many of which have a graduation rate of less than 60%.

Pulling the academically gifted students away from local high schools can have a debilitating effect on both the school and its students. A lower number of high-performing students means less funding for AP classes and a lower average score on standardized tests. Some argue that students are less motivated to perform well in school when they don’t have classmates who challenge them. Years of this process leave many schools without adequate resources and students without a bright future.

But is a lack of funding really the problem?

District-wide budget cuts take a toll on all public schools, and even the magnet schools have to find ways to cut costs. Perhaps our problems could be solved by looking at some unquantifiable aspects of the high school experience.

Most high school students complain about being bored in class. Even if you’re fascinated by the topic, class can get to be a drag. Some point fingers at the standardized curriculum, arguing that a text-driven classroom does not encourage students to think critically about the subject material, only to parrot information back on a test. However, the right teacher can turn even the dullest lesson into an engaging experience.

Every student at SLA can name at least one of our teachers who have significantly impacted them at some point. Teachers who are committed to their job and excited to help kids learn can make a lasting difference in a student’s motivation and engagement in class. However, schools continue to perform poorly despite hiring veteran teachers.

Could this mean that the students themselves are the problem?

Some students are driven to succeed while others seem content to just barely get by or not to try at all. Is this is personal choice or are the students behaving according to what their peers, teachers, and community expect of them?

While progress in school is ideally based on merit, even students who outperform their classmates in a comprehensive high school will, in all likelihood, not become as successful as the average magnet school student. With this knowledge, simply attending a neighborhood school can have a negative effect on a student’s desire to succeed. At a comprehensive high school, they will be surrounded with students (and teachers) who are not excited about learning and optimistic about their future.

When such a distinction exists between comprehensive and magnet schools, the latter may seem like a struggling student’s only chance at success. However, a student who does not perform well in middle school will probably not be accepted to a selective high school. As a result, they will not have access to the resources that the school offers such as SAT prep and college counseling.

So, do magnet schools transform students into hardworking, college-ready learners, or do they simply enhance the abilities of those students who were born to succeed?

There’s really only one way to find out, but it can’t happen as long as magnet schools separate the high-achieving students from the rest of Philadelphia’s youth. While these schools give advanced students a chance to further prove their skills, there’s no reason why they can’t do so while attending school with the low-performers.

There’s nothing wrong with magnet schools. The problem is simply that they only exist because the alternatives are not good enough. We need to focus our efforts on improving all of our high schools and making sure every student trusts that their school will provide them with a path to success as long as they choose to walk it.

Unsigned editorials are written and approved by the SLAMedia Editorial Staff. They do not reflect the opinion of Science Leadership Academy and its employees.

Filed Under: Op/Ed

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

* Copy This Password *

* Type Or Paste Password Here *

123,678 Spam Comments Blocked so far by Spam Free Wordpress

Primary Sidebar

FacebookInstagramTwitter Snapchat

Features

New Teacher Profile: Alexis Clancy

Braylon Dunlap Staff Writer As many people know, there are a few new additions to SLA’s staff this year with a brand new member being History Teacher Alexis Clancy. If you’re in her advisory or African American history class you may have already met her but there are some other interesting things about Ms. Clancy […]

New Teacher Profile: Mercedes Broughton-Garcia

By Maya Smelser Staff Writer SLA recently welcomed Spanish teacher Mercedes Broughton-Garcia, or Ms. Garcia to her students. After spending 7 years as a science teacher next door at Ben Franklin High School, she is transitioning to life at SLA. Background & Family Life “That’s a loaded question,” Ms. Garcia replied when asked where she […]

Wardrobe of SLA

By Harper Leary Staff Writer Philadelphia is a diverse city, and the student population of Science Leadership Academy reflects that fact— not just with their identities, but also with their fashion choices. If you walk down the hallways of SLA, your head will turn every which way to get a glimpse of all the different […]

How the Pandemic has Changed Live Events

By Maya Smelser & Anouk Ghosh-Poulshock Staff Writers Everyone remembers their first concert. But when the pandemic hit, many tours were canceled or rescheduled. There was a hiatus from live music as people adjusted to their new lives– so many teens missed out on their early concert experiences..  In the past few months, however, concerts […]

How Are SLA Students Are Dealing With Their Last Quarter?

Leticia Desouza Staff Writer After a long yet quick year at SLA, students from different grades have experienced many new things they weren’t able to experience during the 2020-2021 online academic year. After almost 10 months of being back in school, students have encountered difficulties and new experiences that further molded how the rest of […]

Categories

  • A&E
  • Cartoons
  • Covid
  • Faces of 440
  • Features
  • Movies
  • Movies
  • Multimedia
  • News
  • Op/Ed
  • Photos
  • Sports
  • The Rocket Record
  • Uncategorized

Recent Comments

  • martin on Song Review: “Origo”
  • Mekhi Granby on Album Review: Restoration of An American Idol
  • Meymey Seng on Album Review: Culture by Migos
  • Kelsey Brown on Album Review: Restoration of An American Idol
  • Angela Rice on SLA’s New Building Engineer, Ikea

Copyright © 2025 · Metro Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in