• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

SLA Media

SLAMedia is a publication of the news for the Science Leadership Academy community. Writers come from the student body in 10th, 11th, and 12th grades. We work in unison to create a functioning paper with biweekly postings on a variety of events.

  • News
  • Features
  • Sports
  • A&E
  • Op/Ed
  • Multimedia
  • About

Controversy Towards Victoria’s Secret

December 17, 2018 by Jayla Wright Leave a Comment

Juliana Long

Staff Writer

Photo Courtesy of Victoria’s Secret

Not all types of women are accepted in the fashion industry.

Many are outraged at a recent confession from Ed Razek, former CEO of Victoria’s Secret, myself included. Razek was asked in an interview if he would consider having plus sized or trans models in the Victoria’s Secret Fashion shows, to which he replied: “Shouldn’t you have transsexuals in the show? No. No, I don’t think we should. Well, why not? Because the show is a fantasy. It’s a 42-minute entertainment special. That’s what it is.”

The issue with Razek’s comments is tricky to navigate for some including myself. But after some careful analysis and deep thinking, I came to some conclusions about my anger. Right off the bat, he used the term ‘transsexual’ which is no longer an acceptable term when speaking of trans people. The umbrella of ‘trans’ or ‘transgender’ would have been entirely better. This could simply be a case of poor education on trans terminology, but nothing gets better towards the end of his comments.

He goes on to confess that he doesn’t think trans women should be in the fashion show because the show is a “fantasy”. This implies that trans women aren’t as desirable, able to be fantasized, or ultimately truly female as the cisgender models in the show.

The performer at the 2018 Victoria’s Secret Fashion Show, Halsey, wasn’t happy with the CEO’s comments after her performance. She took to Instagram, posting a page long piece on why she was offended by Razek’s comments. She claimed that as a member of the LGBT+ community, she does not tolerate exclusivity and that people’s anger towards Razek should be redirected to organizations that protect LGBT+ rights such as GLSEN.

After being criticized by many, Razek took to Twitter with a rather short apology, which didn’t charm me.

He pulled a classic “I’m going to apologize for your offense, not for being offensive” by apologizing that people interpreted his comments as transphobic. He then claims that trans women have come to castings but never made it, claiming it was “never about gender”. He digs himself an even deeper hole with this remark since it has even more transphobic undertones & implications.

Razek contracts himself by claiming to reject trans women in castings was “never about gender”, while simultaneously pointing out that they’re trans.  Just by categorizing trans women auditions as separate from cis women auditions means that that gender has something to do with it.

If gender had nothing to do with it, Victoria’s Secret shows would feature a mix of both cis and trans women. His comments claim not to ostracize trans women, but they still close them off from any opportunity to participate in the fashion show.

Victoria’s Secret is arguably the most popular lingerie company in the US, and it’s a symbol of feminine beauty, sexuality, and confidence for many women across the country. The company’s leader is now a known transphobe – so now these aspects of femininity have been revoked from trans women in a way. They’ve essentially been left out of one of the main symbols of beauty in the country. And until they start being allowed to participate in the VS fashion shows and other popular modes of representation, they’ll continue to get excluded from the definition of beauty altogether.

Filed Under: Features

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

* Copy This Password *

* Type Or Paste Password Here *

101,385 Spam Comments Blocked so far by Spam Free Wordpress

Primary Sidebar

FacebookInstagramTwitter Snapchat

Features

New Teacher Profile: Alexis Clancy

Braylon Dunlap Staff Writer As many people know, there are a few new additions to SLA’s staff this year with a brand new member being History Teacher Alexis Clancy. If you’re in her advisory or African American history class you may have already met her but there are some other interesting things about Ms. Clancy […]

New Teacher Profile: Mercedes Broughton-Garcia

By Maya Smelser Staff Writer SLA recently welcomed Spanish teacher Mercedes Broughton-Garcia, or Ms. Garcia to her students. After spending 7 years as a science teacher next door at Ben Franklin High School, she is transitioning to life at SLA. Background & Family Life “That’s a loaded question,” Ms. Garcia replied when asked where she […]

Wardrobe of SLA

By Harper Leary Staff Writer Philadelphia is a diverse city, and the student population of Science Leadership Academy reflects that fact— not just with their identities, but also with their fashion choices. If you walk down the hallways of SLA, your head will turn every which way to get a glimpse of all the different […]

How the Pandemic has Changed Live Events

By Maya Smelser & Anouk Ghosh-Poulshock Staff Writers Everyone remembers their first concert. But when the pandemic hit, many tours were canceled or rescheduled. There was a hiatus from live music as people adjusted to their new lives– so many teens missed out on their early concert experiences..  In the past few months, however, concerts […]

How Are SLA Students Are Dealing With Their Last Quarter?

Leticia Desouza Staff Writer After a long yet quick year at SLA, students from different grades have experienced many new things they weren’t able to experience during the 2020-2021 online academic year. After almost 10 months of being back in school, students have encountered difficulties and new experiences that further molded how the rest of […]

Copyright © 2023 · Metro Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in